Tate: Mommy, close your eyes.*
Jenny: Um, okay.
T: Okay, open your eyes.
Tate appears to be sitting in the tub, exactly as before.
J: What's up?
T: Okay, when you closed your eyes, you did NOT see me pee in the tub.
J: (exasperated) Tate, did you pee in the tub?!
T: Did you see me pee in the tub?
*Tate is always doing the "Close your eyes" trick. Usually you do it and he makes a car or a dinosaur "appear." Not always. But there is nothing unusual about the "Close your eyes" request in and of itself.